Ariel was then asked if there were anything else that the deputies should know about.
When asked if she had anything else, deputies said she pulled a foot-long alligator out of her yoga trousers and placed it in the truck bed. But when they searched Machan-Le Quire's backpack, they discovered "41 small turtles".
Things then got even more weird when she proceeded to pull a one-foot baby alligator out of her trousers.
Charlotte County Sheriff's Office deputies stopped the vehicle at around 3 a.m. after it blew through a stop sign, WBBH reported. She also had 41 3-stripe turtles in the vehicle.
NBC Miami called the incident an "only in Florida" moment.
She then pulled the one-foot alligator from her pants.
Charlotte Country Sheriff's office saw the amusing side of the unusual situation, sharing a hilarious post to Facebook.
The Florida Fish Wildlife and Conservation Commission arrived at the scene to continue the investigation. The critters have since been seized and released back into the wild.
The woman was cited for possession and bag limit violations for all three species, which are native to Florida but are regulated.
CCSO PIO Katie Heck usually posts about serious matters.
The FWC did not immediately respond to PEOPLE's request for comment.